Islanders vs Blue Jackets Picks and Prediction – 4/17/2025

The New York Islanders (35–34–12) travel to Nationwide Arena to face the Columbus Blue Jackets (39–33–9) in a pivotal Metropolitan Division clash. With playoff implications on the line, both teams aim to secure a crucial victory. Puck drop is scheduled for 7:00 PM ET, with coverage on ESPN+. ​Get in on all the hockey action with our free NHL picks.

The Islanders are battling for a playoff spot, currently holding a 35–34–12 record. They've averaged 2.73 goals per game while allowing 2.81. Their power play has struggled, converting at a 12.6% rate, and their penalty kill stands at 71.7%. Captain Anders Lee has been a consistent performer with 54 points (29 goals, 25 assists). Bo Horvat also provides prolific offense with 28 goals and 29 assists. Injuries have impacted the roster, with key players like Mathew Barzal and Semyon Varlamov sidelined. ​

The Blue Jackets are on a five-game winning streak, boasting a 39–33–9 record. They've been potent offensively, averaging 3.22 goals per game, and have a power play efficiency of 21.6%. Kirill Marchenko has been on a heater with 73 points (31 goals, 42 assists). Zach Werenski remains a mainstay of this offense, contributing a team-leading 80 points on the season. Defensively, they've allowed 3.12 goals per game. Injuries include forward Kevin Labanc (out for the season) and goaltender Elvis Merzlikins (day-to-day). ​

Given Columbus's current form and home advantage, they are our side to win this matchup. Columbus is on a roll and the Islanders’ offense is so weak that we cannot get behind them against most teams this season. A streaking Blue Jackets team will get a good win here. Prediction: Blue Jackets win this one by a score of 4-2.