Yankees vs Blue Jays Picks and Prediction – 7/23/2025

This Wednesday, Max Fried takes the hill for the New York Yankees against Chris Bassitt and the Toronto Blue Jays in the second game of their heated AL East series. Get our free MLB Picks all season long! New York edged Toronto 5-4 on Tuesday and will try to keep the momentum rolling as the division race tightens.

Fried, acquired midseason in a blockbuster deal, has settled in quickly. His poise and command have stabilized the Yankees’ rotation. With a deep arsenal of pitches, he’s capable of keeping the Blue Jays’ right-handed-heavy lineup in check, if he avoids early trouble and keeps his pitch count manageable.

Bassitt, meanwhile, will be aiming to bounce back after a tough outing. His ability to mix speeds and keep hitters guessing makes him effective, though he’ll need strong support from Toronto’s defense and bullpen. Offensively, the Jays continue to lean on timely hits from Bo Bichette and Vladimir Guerrero Jr., but consistency remains a concern.

The Yankees’ lineup has looked more balanced of late, and their late-game bullpen edge could be the difference again. With Fried on the mound, they’ll feel confident closing out another tight contest north of the border.

The Yankees’ depth and bullpen edge give them a late-game advantage over the Blue Jays in this closely matched showdown. With Fried pitching effectively and timely hitting from their lineup, New York should have enough to close it out. Expect a tense finish. Take the Yankees to win the game and the series. Final Score Prediction, New York Yankees win 4-2.