Cardinals vs Brewers Picks and Prediction – 5/9/2024

The Milwaukee Brewers will settle in for a Thursday Night matchup against division foe, the St. Louis Cardinals. The Brew Crew is looking to ramp back up after their hot start has cooled. For other MLB action see our MLB Picks.

Milwaukee Brewers MLB Prop Bets - Thursday - 5/9/24

Tobias Myers Under 2.5 earned runs

Both Teams: No run first inning

St. Louis Cardinals: Team total Under

Tobias Myers

Tobias Myers has not been great in 2024. However, this gives us a good line to fade the weak Cardinals offense. Myers will be able to give this lineup some issues with his breaking ball. He has given up four runs in his last two outings and we will sweat out the Under 2.5.

The Pick: Under 2.5 earned runs

Both teams

Along the same narrative we like Myers to go under his earned runs total, the Cardinals just do not have a lot of pop on offense. We will take advantage of the most exciting bet in baseball, the no run first inning (NRFI).

The Pick: No run first inning

St. Louis Cardinals

We expect this to be a low scoring game between two pitchers with control on the mound, that bodes well for the Under on the total. We lean toward the Brewers to win, so the safer prop to play is simply the Cardinals to go under their team total.

The Pick: Team total Under 4.5