Red Sox vs Yankees Picks and Prediction – 9/12/2024

By: Garrett Beaverson |

Last Updated: 09/11/2024 at 10:59 PM ET

Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees 09/12/24 - MLB Picks & Predictions
Game Start: 9/12/2024, 11:15 PM UTC
Latest Odds: NYY -165 ; O/U 9

Red Sox vs Yankees Prediction

The Boston Red Sox travel to the Bronx to face off against their long-time rivals, the New York Yankees, in what promises to be another chapter of their storied rivalry. The intensity of the Red Sox-Yankees rivalry ensures that this series will be nothing short of thrilling. Get in on all the action with our free MLB picks.

The Boston Red Sox (74-72) have seen ups and downs this season, but they continue to fight for respectability as the season winds down. Rafael Devers remains the centerpiece of Boston’s lineup, cranking out 28 home runs and 81 RBIs. His power bat is critical for the Red Sox, especially in the hitter-friendly confines of Yankee Stadium. The Red Sox will look to Cooper Criswell to take the mound, who enters the game with a 4.11 ERA. Criswell’s ability to control the strike zone and keep the Yankees’ hitters off balance will be key for Boston’s chances.

On the other side, the New York Yankees (83-62) have returned to their juggernaut form and would love nothing more than to take down Boston. Aaron Judge remains the biggest threat in the Yankees’ lineup, with 51 home runs. Alongside Judge, Juan Soto has elevated the Yankees to world championship level with 100 RBIs.

Red Sox vs Yankees Pick Analysis

The Yankees may have looked the better team for much of the season, but they have cooled down the stretch. Boston can win against anyone and will be motivated for this matchup. We like the value on the Red Sox to cash as a pretty big underdog. Prediction: Boston wins 6-5.

Our Free MLB Pick for New York Yankees vs Boston Red Sox